A tale of two PMs

I want to make a comparison between two Australian prime ministers and their reactions when confronted by the views of the people.

Billy Hughes (1915-1923) wanted to implement conscription during the first world war. Julia Gillard (2010-soon) wants to implement a carbon dioxide tax after she stabbed her predecessor in the back over a similar plan.

Hughes, a competent and inspiring wartime leader was confronted with dissent by the Australian people over his plan. Gillard, an incompetent and distrustful politician is confronted with dissent over her scheme.

Hughes, chose the democratic path and took conscription to a plebiscite, twice. Gillard ignored the democratic path and dismissed calls by Tony Abbott for a plebiscite. She will not call an election either.

Hughes failed in his bid for conscription and although he continued to advocate it, he accepted the position of the Australian people. Gillard won’t even give us a say, having lied before the election about not introducing a carbon tax. Barring a miracle she will get her way.

I realise that they are two separate issues with different implications. Conscription would have put the lives of thousands of young Australian men at risk. A carbon tax will put the livelihoods of most Australians at risk. Given the magnitude of the move and the community backlash Gillard is already receiving, we should get a say. She has put the Australian economy into the toilet and within a year, will press the full flush button. I think this warrants some kind of input from the stake holders of this decision.


About Climate Nonconformist

Hi, I'm the climatenonconformist (not my real name), and I am a global warming skeptic, among the few in generation Y. With Australia facing the prospect of a carbon tax, we need to be asking the simple question; where is the evidence that our emissions are causing any dangerous warming?
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to A tale of two PMs

  1. Deadman says:

    Even without conscription, 416,809 men chose to enlist from a total population of under five million.
    Now, whether we like it or not, without a vote, without a say, we shall have a tax which even supporters admit will do nothing for the environment other than, they hope, to persuade taxpayers to reduce their energy consumption. Even if this incompetent government be toppled before it can impose the tax, that contemptible lack of reasoning amongst political leaders (from all sides, here and elsewhere), supported by a largely compliant, sycophantic media, is worryingly dangerous for any important decision in the future.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s